http://gritsforbreakfast.blogspot.com/2010/11/houston-wants-to-continue-red-light.html

Saturday, November 06, 2010
Houston wants to continue red-light cameras after voters rejected them

Whenever red-light cameras are proposed, we're always told the goal is public safety, not revenue generation. But after Houston voters elected to remove the cameras, all the official complaints are about the resulting revenue shortfall and the city is looking for ways to keep them running over voters' objections through the end of the current contract. Reports the Houston Chronicle http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/7278330.html :

Although voters abolished Houston's red light camera system Tuesday, the 70 cameras have the green light to keep recording traffic violations for months as the city weighs a legal strategy for exiting its contract with the firm operating the cameras, city officials say.

Anti-camera activists slammed the delay Wednesday, insisting on immediately terminating the five-year contract — whatever the cost - with ATS, the Arizona firm that manages Houston's system. The May 2009 contract has a termination clause that requires the city to provide the company with a 120-day notice of cancellation, a period when the cameras will still be in full operation and civil fines issued, according to the city attorney.

Now the Mayor says elminating the cameras will require multi-million dollar cuts to the police department budget:

Mayor Annise Parker acknowledged the referendum has exacerbated ongoing challenges with the city's budget and noted HPD, which was the recipient of funds from the camera program, would be responsible for cutting its budget to make up for the immediate $10 million gap created by the vote.

"We're going to try to do it in a way that does not impact public safety," she said, although she acknowledged that furloughs or layoffs of city employees may be necessary, a position she has maintained since passing the fiscal 2011 budget with more than $70 million of unrealized revenue and spending cuts.

A column in the Galveston News put it succinctly http://galvestondailynews.com/story/188418:

If red-light cameras are about public safety, no one has made a convincing case.

In Houston, when the election returns showed that voters had put an end to red-light cameras, the story was about money, not about public safety.

The company profiting red-light cameras spent $1.7 million http://www.autoblog.com/2010/11/04/report-red-light-camera-initiatives-lose-big-across-the-country/ to oppose the ballot initiative, a sum which dwarfed camera opponents' spending by 10-1. It didn't matter; voters still rejected the cameras, just as they did in College Station last year. Notably, other jurisdictions across the country rejected red-light cameras wherever they were challenged, this go-round in Mukilteo, Washington; Anaheim, California; and Baytown, Texas.

On Facebook, the group that successfully challenged the cameras is urging Houston drivers not to pay tickets received after the plebiscite http://www.facebook.com/event.php?eid=126711920720571 :

If you currently have a pending RLC ticket do not pay it. They can do nothing to you, can not issue a warrant, can not report you to a credit bureau and you can still register your car. Don't let them scare you. WE WON, don't pay, nothing will happen to you, they only try to scare you out of your $$$$, just don't pay...Read Texas Transportation code 707, if you read it, you will see there is little they can do. :P

Though I'm not a lawyer, from my understanding of the statutes that's probably accurate advice. As a practical matter, the city has no means to collect fines going forward and only dubious legal authority to do so. Either way, whether they're removed now or four months from now, red-light cameras in Houston are a goner. If I had my druthers, the Legislature would follow voters' lead next year and eliminate this misbegotten cash cow across the board.

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Title
Comment	smaller | bigger
Name
Email
Write the displayed characters
Subscribe via email (registered users only)
	Add Comment Preview